PERAN LEMBAGA INTERNASIONAL DALAM PENEGAKAN HUKUM HUMANITER PADA KONFLIK TIMOR LESTE DAN PAPUA
Keywords:
International Humanitarian Law, East Timor, Papua, ICRC, United Nations, International NGOs, Sovereignty, IndonesiaAbstract
The enforcement of international humanitarian law (IHL) in domestic conflicts often intersects with the issue of state sovereignty, particularly when involving the intervention of international actors. This article explores the dynamics of international organizations—such as the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), the United Nations (UN), and global non-governmental organizations (NGOs)—in two critical conflict areas in Indonesia: the armed conflict and subsequent secession of East Timor, and the protracted unrest in Papua. Employing a juridical-critical and historical-qualitative approach, this study systematically distinguishes between the official mandates of these organizations and their actual field operations, which at times have extended beyond the principle of neutrality and influenced the integrity of Indonesia’s national sovereignty. The findings indicate that while certain organizations, such as the ICRC, largely adhered to their humanitarian mandates, others—including the UN and prominent human rights NGOs—played a politically significant role, particularly in facilitating East Timor’s separation from Indonesia. In contrast, international involvement in Papua has been more limited yet continues to exert global pressure through human rights advocacy. Indonesia's defensive yet progressive response has proven effective in preserving sovereignty in Papua, drawing lessons from the East Timor experience. The article recommends a selective synergy between international cooperation and the safeguarding of non-intervention principles, ensuring that the enforcement of humanitarian law is not exploited as a political instrument by foreign entities.
References
Antoulas, S. & Mathez, P. (2002). ICRC Special Report: Goodbye and Thank You – East Timor 1975–2002. International Committee of the Red Cross () ().
Reuters. (23 April 2009). “Indonesia orders ICRC out of Papua over jail visits” (Indonesia orders ICRC out of Papua over jail visits | Reuters).
Human Rights Watch. (20 Dec 2002). “Indonesia’s Court for East Timor a ‘Whitewash’” (Indonesia's Court for East Timor a "Whitewash" (Human Rights Watch Press release, New York, December 20, 2002) .
Robinson, M. (1999). Statements at UN Commission on Human Rights Special Session on East Timor (COMMISSION ON HUMAN RIGHTS OPENS SPECIAL SESSION ON ...).
Human Rights Watch. (2000). Human Rights and Pro-Independence Actions in Papua, 1999-2000 (Indonesia: Human Rights And Pro-Independence Actions In Papua, 1999-2000 - Background).
Kompas.com. (28 Sept 2020). “You are No Representation of Papuans – Indonesia tells Vanuatu at UN” ('You are No Representation of Papuans': Indonesia Tells Vanuatu at UN ).
Asia Pacific Solidarity Network. (2 Juli 2018). “Istana Respons Laporan Amnesty International soal Papua” (APSN | Responding to Amnesty report, government says it's addressing rights problems in Papua).
Wikipedia. (2023). “Indonesian occupation of East Timor” (Indonesian occupation of East Timor - Wikipedia).
Amnesty International. (2018). “Sudah, Kasi Tinggal Dia Mati”: Pembunuhan dan Impunitas di Papua (Laporan Amnesty Internasional Indonesia) (APSN | Responding to Amnesty report, government says it's addressing rights problems in Papua).
United Nations Press Release SC/6913. (15 Sept 2000). Security Council Resolution 1319 on West Timor (United Nations Security Council Resolution 1319 - Wikipedia).
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 JOURNAL OF LAW AND NATION

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.